When new parents say that they wish that the baby was born with directions, veteran parents soothe those debutant nerves with the reassurance that instincts will soon kick in, and the rest, well, we figure it out.
I have been on both sides of that conversation. The lost new mom. Feeling helpless. Totally in the dark. Screaming baby, crying baby, hungry baby, soiled baby, tired baby; each cry means something else, apparently, supposedly, but when was I going to be able to identify which cry signals which problem? Eventually, I the ability manifested. And then he learned to communicate, and then he learned to actually speak (mommy, this water gun looks like a geyser! Mommy, this tastes yucky…,) and now, while navigating toddlerdom is a different beast from the infant days (thankfully!), that overwhelming sensation of cluelessness has dissipated, and I’m not longer stuck in that fog of panic otherwise known as, “I am just trying not to break the baby…” (How many new moms knew how wiggly a newborn could be?) And as recently as this week, I got to be the friend who sincerely meant it when telling her friend of a 6 weeks old, it gets easier. Much much easier. (Well, depends on how you define easier… what I meant was, you get the hang of it.)
I wish that I could say the same thing for potty training. That it gets easier. That being a parent for the last 3+ years clues you into the mysteries of why poop in the potty is such an up hill battle.
For me, 3 years was totally inadequate preparation for the 7 months that I can now proudly say are behind us.
For this, there needs to be a primer. Here is mine.
And I don’t mean Dr. So and So’s suggestions, declarations, methods, and guarantees, available in hardcover, soft bound, signed, 2nd and 3rd editions, kindle, glossy excerpt from I’m A Better Parent than You magazine, and the lecture with visuals available on You Tube… I mean, the “Hey, I totally understand that the sticker chart and M&M reward route didn’t do a damn thing to get your kid potty trained; here’s the helpful suggestion for training the impossible to train toddler who should otherwise be trained.”
Yup. That’s us. And why shouldn’t it be? Not like Alex has been easy, typical, or generally quiet, calm, or compliant with any other aspect of daily life (um, let’s not even talk about staying put in his own bed…) it just wouldn’t be as fun…
1. The sticker chart. Months 24-36.
Yes. We tried this from the beginning. Right after his 2nd birthday I purchased a snazzy little pea soup green Baby Bjorn potty (it matched the walls on the master bedroom in our other house) and kept it in the master bathroom. He used to sit on it fully clothed, pick it up, walk around with it, put it on his head (never used at this point) but the interest stopped there. After showers and first thing in the morning I started sitting him on the potty, letting him see that there was nothing scary about it, hoping that he’d take to it. He’d pee once in a while. Sometimes he’d just sit there for 10, 12. 14 minutes, watching Seasame Street or some other mind numbing educational children’s program. (Who the hell developed Wonder Pets? Shoot Me Now.) Since he was a) young b) boy, I didn’t push anything, and it became clear to me, potty training was not at all on the child’s to-do list. But we kept at it all year, mornings and evenings on the potty to pee. That’s about it. He’d get a sticker for going pee, and at first he cared about what sticker he would get, but after a while, the sticker phenomenon got old, he realized, it’s just a sticker, you can’t play with a sticker, it doesn’t make a noise, it doesn’t taste like chocolate, and you cant’ really throw it at mommy or the dogs, so it’s really not much of a reward. Turns out, the child really doesn’t care about stickers. Stickers = bust.
2. Elmo Goes Potty. Months 24-36.
I naively thought that if Alex watched the DVD I purchased, Elmo goes potty, he’d want to emulate the behavior. I was so stupid.
3. M&M’s. Months 36-38.
Not really wanting to introduce the child to candy, I did my benefit/risk analysis, and figured savings in diapers outweighed fear of dental complications (and our dentist told me his teeth looked great on our last visit thanks to his general distaste for hard or gummy candy and lack of love for juices), so I bought a giant bag (as in, multiple lbs) of M&M’s that to this day is kept in our master bathroom above a vanity cabinet, and as of his 3rd birthday, if he went pee pee in the potty, he’d get to choose 3 colors. This started to show some progress. In the meantime, we moved into a bigger house, so I realized we needed more than 1 potty if we wanted to reach the goal in time. Two more potty purchases later (1 for the car, 1 for the downstairs bath, the other upstairs) and I was ready to go. We continued the M&M reward method until we had a huge bag of M&M’s, minus all the blue ones. Apparently the blue ones tasted better. It was sometime February, and while he’d pee on the potty when sat there and bribed, he still wouldn’t go on his own, wouldn’t forewarn us, and usually fought the whole process. Things were not going well.
4. Shooting Pee.
Boys like to shoot things. It’s something inherent in the DNA, even if you don’t let them play with guns, they manage to turn everything into a gun – Alex first learned about guns at Disneyland of all places… Thanks to the Buzz Lightyear ride. It’s like a lightbulb went off in his head, his testosterone kicked into high gear, and well… as a girlfriend put it plainly, they were raised to be Spartans, can’t fight the Gladiator urge. So, I tried the recommend method of telling him to “shoot” pee into the toilet. I even had thin paper based toilet friendly targets that you throw into the toilet so the kid can take aim. He didn’t buy it. Bust.
5. Naked Potty Training.
A lot of parents swear by this method, and so of course, we gave it a try. It’s usually much easier to master in the summer with the obvious benefit of warm weather, and the trick is to stay at home on lockdown for a weekend or week, keep the kid out of pants and diapers all together, usually in the backyard with a potty in reach, and after a couple accidents, the kid should gravitate towards the potty, recognizing the feeling of the need to go and associating it with heading to the potty to do the Doo.
Not as simple as it sounds. And I will illustrate with actual examples.
The following is true.
a) Naked potty training on a warm early spring day. Naked child runs through mom and dad’s bathroom, asks dad to open the door to the master balcony off the bathroom. Dad accommodates, takes son out onto balcony to view backyard. Dad starts laughing hysterically. Mom walks out on the balcony to find out what’s so funny. Mom witnesses toddler peeing off the balcony, finding it extremely funny, laughing hysterically, dad can’t keep from laughing along. Mom mortified. BUST.
b) Mom put child on potty, who goes pee. Mom pleased, flushes pee, washes son’s hands and her own. While washing her own hands, son runs into hallway. Comes back into the bedroom.
“I made poo poo.”
Confused look on mom’s face.
“You made what?”
“I made poo poo. Big poo poo.”
“What do you mean you made big poo poo? Where?”
“Out there.” Son points to doorway.
I don’t even need to finish the story. You can figured it out. Mom mortified. BUST. We gave up on the naked potty training.
6. Months 38… On… Big Ticket Bribery.
Finally, I had to take matters into my own hands and use what I knew would work with our son – the gift of lightsabers that actually make noise and light up, water guns, large scale lawn mower bubbles makers, toy cars (yay for the $1 bins), trucks, books, cheap DVD’s, gooey chocolates in blue wrappers (Dove coconut Easter candy), and pool noodles. Mind you, this was still cheaper than a month’s worth of diapers, so it was worth a shot. I made massive purchases at Toys R Us and Wal-Mart of the above-mentioned items, put them in a huge box in the downstairs guest room in plain sight of the adjoining bathroom, and explained to Alex that if he peed in the potty (and we finally switched to the regular toilet, much easier, cleaner, and would get him used to public restrooms faster) he would get a small toy, and if he pooped in the potty he would get one of the big ticket items (as in lightsabers, bubble blower, Star Wars Storm Trooper guns, etc…). Soon enough, Alex was peeing in the potty, and amassing a fine collection of water guns (pack of 5 for $1 goes a long way). By this point, we were heading to Florida, and I was getting desperate. Poop still wasn’t happening in the potty.
7. Star Wars Cookies
An obvious reward tactic is finding something that your kid loves, and running with it. Obviously, my box of tricks was going to run out and I really didn’t want to spend a fortune restocking toys for a toddler who is already a tad bit spoiled, slightly over-indulged, so I needed a Plan B. (And yes, I know my kid is terribly spoiled in some respects. We’re addressing this slowly…)
The easiest and economical solution: Williams Sonoma just happened to come out with Star Wars cookie molds – and voila! Every pee in the potty landed him his choice of a Star Wars shaped cookies – Yoda, Darth Vader, Boba Fett, or Storm Trooper. But poop was still a problem.
8. Feeding the Hungry Potty.
I bet you didn’t know that some kids have major anxiety about potty training, something to do with the flushing sounds, and not understanding where everything goes. I started to understand that this was most likely Alex’s major obstacle, and I needed a creative solution to properly deal with it. This is where having amazing mom friends comes in very handy. I bumped into a girlfriend of mine and her girlfriend, and we get to talking, and we all have boys, potty training topic naturally comes up, and then they enlightened me on the brilliant methodology for dealing with a kid who was clearly anxious about the process; tell the child that the potty is hungry and needs to be fed, his mouth his wide open and ready to eat, and when he flushes, he says thank you. First, I couldn’t stop laughing when I heard this because it was so simple, slightly ridiculous, kind of gross. But, desperate as I was, I was willing to try it. Believe it or not, this worked for us. Alex started to sort of befriend the potty, it wasn’t a scary thing but a hungry household staple, and needed to be fed. The anxiety began to lessen, I could see the light at the end of the tunnel. Finally, one day before karate, I knew he had to poop, he did the dance, a short of shimmy with a nervous face and attempted to run away from me to go hide under the billiard table (don’t ask if you can’t figure it out), I caught him and ran him to the bathroom, and for 30 minutes I begged and pleaded for him to poop in the potty, I brought out the big ticket bubble gun blower that was shaped like a lawn mower trimmer thing, let him hold it, pleaded with him to feed the potty… AND WE DID IT! (I think I cried.) We were ready to head to Florida.
9. No Other Choice. Months 41+
In the Keys, we were in the pool for hours at a time and at the beach, and we explained to Alex that he wouldn’t be allowed at either activity if he didn’t go on the potty. He loved the warm waters of the lagoon, ocean and pool and the friends he got to play with - we didn’t have the big box of toys but we had the threat of going back to the hotel room and staying there. Who knew all we needed to do was go on a tropical vacation to get the ball continually rolling?
10. Contiued reward, accolades, applause…
From his 3rd birthday, it took a solid 7 months to really nail down the whole process, to get him to tell us when we needed to go, and to actually sit down and go without major argument. To this day, he still says “No Thanks” when I ask if he has to go, and then direct him to the potty anyway only to see that yup, he had to go… he just didn’t want to stop whatever it was that he was doing. We had a lot of accidents along the way, and once in a while, they still happen – which is why I always carry a change of clothes in the Darth Vader back pack. We remind him that Jedi’s go in the potty, and we’ve even called Yoda to tell him about poop in the potty, and Alex is very proud when he learns that Yoda is impressed with his achievement. It took patience I didn’t think I had, and sometimes… didn’t actually have – there were plenty of times when Pete got frustrated and desperate emails from me, not understanding what I was doing wrong, why other kids potty trained in 3 days, 2 weeks, and we were struggling for months; I needed to make sure this happened, since a prerequisite to his new preschool which absolutely HAD TO HAPPEN was a diaper-free status. I had known he was ready since for the last year he stayed dry through the night, but it took me a while to understand the right way to go about doing this.
I actually learned a valuable lesson through this rather frustrating milestone process. I was reminded that kids are not cookie cutter, and what works for one may not work for another; and the fact that one kid was trained by age 2, and another trained in a weekend, has absolutely no bearing on what our experience will be like, and it’s unfair of me to make any sort of comparison.
I’m beyond thrilled to be out of diapers, although it’s a funny feeling – he’s definitely not my little baby anymore… now he’s my big ol’ baby… 41 lbs, 41 inches. It’s a relief that we’re in Buzz Lightning undies and preschool starts this Fall!